What To Do When We Can’t Agree About Care For Someone?
Choosing the right type of care for someone is never straightforward and it is common for disagreements to arise amongst family and friends, or between state bodies such as the NHS or local authority and those same family and friends, especially when powers of attorney or deputyships are involved.
The person at the centre of the decision
Often overlooked in disputed decisions about care is the person at the centre of the decision. It is an important principle under the Mental Capacity Act to remember that a person is assumed to have capacity to make a decision about their care, unless it is established that they don’t.
It is also vital to consider that mental capacity is ‘decision-specific’ and therefore just because someone lacks capacity to make specific financial decisions, it does not mean they lack capacity to make a decision about their care.
Wherever possible the person at the centre of the decision should be consulted and involved in the decision about their care. They should not be overlooked simply because they may have a certain diagnosis or may be confused at times. However, it is also important to remember that decisions about care choices must be in that person’s best interests and may not always be the same as their wishes.
Your role
When helping decide the right type of care for someone it is important to understand your individual role in the process. You should consider whether you hold a formal position of responsibility such as power of attorney or a court appointed deputyship, or whether you are acting as the person’s ‘next of kin’ or a concerned family member. This is where advice about where you stand is key.
It is important to remember that whilst a formal position of responsibility such as a power of attorney for health and welfare does give you some specific decision-making authority, it is not a power without limits. As an attorney (or deputy), you will be subject to specific duties which must be considered carefully before any decision is made. On the flip side, just because you do not have any formal authority, it does not mean you do not have a say. With our support we can ensure your voice is heard and if necessary, apply to the Court of Protection to protect the individual concerned.
The care decision
Decisions about care are often both a health and financial matter. Conflicts can often arise when people prioritise one aspect over the other or seek to use a power which grants them authority over one aspect only.
Care itself can take many forms, from formal care or nursing home placements through to informal care arrangements between family members, often undocumented. There is no ‘one size fits all approach’ and context and individual circumstance is crucial. The need for this individuality can often come up against inflexible policies and procedures of local authorities or the NHS, which can feel like you are hitting your head against a brick wall.
In addition, as family dynamics become increasingly complex or blended, the risk of disagreement is growing, with opinions on the ‘right choice of care’ varying dramatically based on personal background, trauma and experience.
How we can help?
Our Court of Protection team is experienced at working on behalf of a range of individuals concerned with someone’s care. Whether you are an attorney, a deputy, next of kin or a concerned family member or friend, we can give you practical advice about and how to navigate any disagreements.
Our team of experts, where appropriate, can help mediate family roundtable discussions or become involved in best interest meetings. They also regular assist clients in making referrals to or acting in response to safeguarding bodies such as the Office of the Public Guardian or Adult Social Care. They also frequently make applications to the Court of Protection and will give you an honest opinion about your chance of success and the associated risks.
To ensure you have clarity about what to expect, we can offer fixed fee initial appointments to provide you with clear advice about the best way forward. If you aren’t sure whether your matter is something we can assist with then please do get in touch as the team will offer a free initial call to confirm whether it is something we can help with.